Login/Join

The more things change...

Discussion
Jun 30, 2009
Keywords
Interests

  If the more things change then more they stay the same, when are things really going to change?

    It seems at times that nothing is really changing in the world.  We still have war, poverty, disease, death and the entire spectrum of things that most people believe will be eradicated when we arrive at the ideal future.  Will this ideal of a perfect world ever happen?
For all of the achievements of man, we seem to be stagnating.  Computers are bigger, faster and more powerful but what has that really done to improve the life of an everyday person?  Can a computer feed the homeless?  Can it teach someone to read?  Can it solve all our problems?
 

Take for example this item from the 1950's:

Picture courtesy of A. Currell from Flickr

 

and compare it to this cutting edge item from today:

Picture courtesy of Casey Marshall from Flickr
 

    In fifty years we have been able to push the boundaries of technology and science yet we still have to vacuum our damn floors the same way.  Yes the machine may be more aerodynamic, more efficient, more powerful but in the end you still have to use it the same way for the same result.

 

    Sometimes it feels like we are on a ongoing Merry-Go-Round where the same issues and problems arise again and again and again.  What will it take to really break the cycle?

 

In the following two pictures we have Americans out of work, desperate to find a new job.

 

Photo Credit: National Archive
 
Photo Credit: Reuters Pictures

 

    In both cases we have people caught in a depression, standing on long lines in the hopes of finding a job.  Why didn't we learn the lessons from the past and stop this kind of thing from happening again?  I am sure that no one ever wanted another Great Depression but somehow it has happened again.  We have cell phones, MSNBC, the Internet, computers and a million other technological wonders but somehow even with all our advances we have an economy that has ground itself to a halt.  When will we get real change?

 

   This idea of the more things stay the same has a further link with the Great Depression when you examine the administrations who tried to fix the economy.  We can easily draw similarities between Roosevelt's New Deal and Obama's current recovery plans.  In both cases improving infrastructure and public works projects were a key area in stimulating growth.  Although many of the factors involving the economic slowdown and factors complicating the recovery are different, the current crisis seems like a place that we have visited before.

 

    Man has evolved from using a club to kill another man, to using the power of the atom to kill millions of people at a time.  All that has changed is the scope of the damage we can inflict.  When will real change come?  Will technology lead the way or is technology just window dressing at maintaining the status quo?

Comments

It's weird, to me the

Submitted by JABenitez180 on Tue, 2009-06-30 12:49.

It's weird, to me the machines look more similar than different. Yes, there are obvious difference but just looking at the two images I notice the lack of change in structure and design.

You need a revolution to spark a change. Otherwise things will remain constant without really evolving or changing. iTunes has recently changed their pricing of songs. Songs are no longer .99 cents but vary between $.99 and $1.29. The whole idea of iTunes was to buy individual songs at a seemingly fair price. It's not fair, to me, when the price is over a dollar and some songs require you to buy the entire album just to listen to that one song you wanted.

It seems like I was already here at some point before.

Prototypes and models are

Submitted by mwhitehouse on Tue, 2009-06-30 12:55.

Prototypes and models are powerful guides. That's one thing that worries me when I provide exemplars to my students. Do they function to engender excellence or prevent thinking outside the box.

BTW: Rosanne (the comedian) says that if men had to vacuum, we would ride them like lawnmowers.

I would love a vacuum

Submitted by JABenitez180 on Tue, 2009-06-30 13:09.

I would love a vacuum designed like ride 'em lawnmower. It would be fun but then I think about the space in my bedroom and, sadly, it would an impossible task to vacuum the carpet unless it's a vacuum I can grasp in my hand.

I think human nature hasn't

Submitted by klevy on Tue, 2009-06-30 13:30.

I think human nature hasn't changed and perhaps never will. It's so much easier and faster to advance in technology than for human beings to be kinder to each other.

Karen Levy, Library Media Specialist
Columbus Campus H.S.
925 Astor Avenue
Bronx, N.Y. 10469

I unfortunately agree with

Submitted by EvilArtTeacher on Tue, 2009-06-30 13:35.

I unfortunately agree with you.  I think people are more into their new ipods and cell phones instead of basic human caring.

Even when asked to shut

Submitted by Susan Harts on Thu, 2009-07-02 13:32.

Even when asked to shut phones off at a recent performance of "Mary Poppins" the man sitting in front of me still had to check his messages (maybe if he were Obama I might not have been so annyoed) - which of course illuminated his seat the the two seats on either side of him - frankly almost ruining my "Feed the Birds" moment. 

I think the vacuum of the

Submitted by wdhaverstock on Tue, 2009-06-30 13:31.

I think the vacuum of the future will look more like a dog house.

In keeping with "the more

Submitted by mwhitehouse on Wed, 2009-07-01 12:45.

In keeping with "the more things change the more they stay the same"... Scientists found this prehistoric car which oddly resembles todays autos.  Click on link below:

www.flickr.com/photos/u2wanderer/2947360587/

 

:)